Category Archives: Geist Reservoir

Geist Reservoir is a Reservoir man made out of Fall Creek in Northeast Indianapolis and Southeast Fishers, Indiana. The area is home to many Indiana local celebrities, politicians, and professional athletes. There is a marina and a waterfront Restaurant named Bella Vita. The public marina has boat slip rentals that run from approximately $1500-$2500 a season. On the lake you can enjoy skiing, wakeboarding, fishing, and just taking a casual boat ride around the lake. Bella Vita serves Italian/Seafood American food and is very good. There are several other bars and restaurants in the marina area including Puccinis and Eddy’s as well. For non boaters there are many walking trails and other attractions such as rolling hills and wooded areas to be enjoyed by all.Geist Reservoir offers many different opportunities in Real Estate. There are many waterfront Geist Homes on the market. There are still several lots available to build the home of your dreams as well. Homes on the main body of the lake tend to be more expensive and homes on the coves are less. Several of my client’s prefer the coves for they are quieter during the boating season due to the coves being “no wake zones”. The views on mainbody are hard to beat and with Real Estate prices being reduced significantly in the current buyer’s market there are many options to choose from. If you are looking to live near the lake but not on it there are many less expensive options as well with some have deeded boat docks.

Click Here to See All Geist Lakefront Homes

Geist Real Estate Market Update June 2019

With Summer off to a great start, Geist Waterfront Real Estate is becoming hotter than ever!

Available Waterfront Homes- 44 Homes for sale ranging from 2.89 million to 90k for a condo!

Waterfront Homes Closed in 2019- 30 ranging from 3.5 million mansion on several waterfront acres to a condo for $91,900.

If you are considering buying or selling a home in the Fishers or Geist Area contact Geist Expert Broker Andrew Neal at 317-371-8133 or [email protected]

Geist Lakefront Real Estate First Quarter 2012 Report

Geist Lakefront Real Estate is starting to heat up with warm weather and Spring almost here!   We are getting excited to get our boat in the water to start our tours soon and wanted to report what is going on in the market.  Currently there are 41  lakefront homes on the market on Geist Reservoir, 5 pending under contract, and 4 closed so far in 2012!   This year is going to be a great year to get a great buy on your lakefront home or to sell your home.  I am predicting we are going to see some great sales this year!    Call Your Geist Waterfront Realtors The Andrew Neal Group at 317-513-7695 to discuss buying or selling a home on Geist Reservoir!  


See All Geist Waterfront Homes For Sale-

Geist Waterfront Home Boat Tours Beginning May 1st, 2012

The Andrew Neal Group is proud to announce we will be offering Geist Reservoir Boat Tours again this year beginning  May 1st, 2012 through October for anyone considering buying or selling a home on Geist Reservoir!   Geist is a beautiful Reservoir with many waterfront housing options from the 400?s up to the Multi-Millions!   If you are selling and want to see your competition,  hear Geist Waterfront expert advise on the value of your home, this tour is for you!    If you are considering buying a home on Geist, trust your Geist waterfront experts to find the perfect home for you.  We can show you the best neighborhoods from Masthead to the Admirals to Cambridge by water!  We will show you where water levels are high and low, and show you the homes with the ideal water views.  Find out how long it takes to get  from the homes by water to your favorite Geist waterfront dining option Bellavita and the top yacht club on the lake Indianapolis Yacht Club.   Don’t just drive and look at homes, see the true side of the home from boat!   Experience the Geist Reservoir Life first hand by boat!

Email us at [email protected]  or call us at 317-513-7695 to setup a tour today!

See all Geist waterfront homes for sale:

*mortgage preapproval letter or proof of funds required for buyers to book tour

Indianapolis Yacht Club, Open House March 4th, 2012!

Indianapolis Yacht Club is a great club located on Geist Reservoir for boaters, families, and anyone who enjoys living the lakefront lifestyle!  Founded in 1956, the club is both a social club and a boating club.   There are boat docks for members, dining, and a lakefront pool!  This is a must for anyone who lives off the lake, boats, and wants to live a social Geist lifestyle.   The club is holding an open house for potential members to come see the club March 4th, 2012!


Geist Waterfront Home Deals

As a Geist Waterfront Real Estate Expert I like to report on what is going on the lake with what is available, selling, and the best deals on the water!   In a few months we will be putting our boat in the water and home boat tours will begin for 2012.   This year is going to be a great year for buying a home on Geist Reservoir!    Low interest rates, improving market conditions, and the fact that many of the Geist homes have come down by 100’s of thousands of dollars throughout the housing correction!  There are many opportunities to buy a great home on the water and you can get a really good deal now!   Here are my favorite Geist Waterfront deals currently…..

Best Geist Waterfront Homes Available

1)12634 Shorevista in Admirals Bay-  6293 sqft for $749,000 short sale!  This home used to be priced at 1.1 million and sits on a near 500k lot with one of the best mainbody views on the lake!

2)12213 Bridgewater Rd. in Bridgewater- 4668sqft custom home on cove in the fabolous Bridgewater neighborhood in Geist,  $599,900!   Wow that is a good deal, I showed this home when it was 750k.    Jump on this deal quick!

3)12998 ROCKY POINTE RD in Cambridge-$799,900- 5557sqft, great cove in a fun neighborhood(see my blog on Cambridge!)

4)8801 Spinnaker Ct.- 1.59 million!-  Gourgeous Mainbody View, main floor master, awesome pool, I am showing this to one of my clients coming in from out of town, and I think they will love this one!  This is a rare great home!


See All Geist Waterfront Homes For Sale-

See All Geist Homes Sold in 2011-

Make sure to DealwithNeal in Geist with all your waterfront Real Estate needs! 317-513-7695 or contact us next to this post!



Waterfront Homes Sold on Geist Reservoir in 2011

This year has been a good year in sales on Geist Reservoir.   As a Geist Waterfront Expert and avid boater, I am always interested in every home coming on the market and how many waterfront homes are selling.   This being near the end of November 2011, 33 waterfront homes on Geist Reservoir have closed.   The highest sale was Reggie Miller’s Home, 20,685sqft on 5.54 acres which just closed 10/14/2011 for 4.5 million! The lowest single family home on the water had a pool and 4229sqft and closed for $350,000. What an  exciting year and we are expecting an even better year next year.  If you are considering selling your home on Geist Reservoir feel free to call us to set up a free listing consultation at 317-814-5530 or you can email us at [email protected].   We would be happy to help if you are considering buying in Geist as well.  During the warmer months we offer boat tours of Geist as well!  Below is a list of the waterfront Geist homes that have sold in 2011!

See All Geist Waterfront Homes Currently For Sale-

33 Waterfront Geist Homes Sold in 2011-

14301 E 113th ST Fishers- 4.5 million

391 BREAKWATER DR Fishers- 2.25 million

11647 Fall Creek Indy- 1.225 million

9080 Bay Breeze CT Indy- 1.225 million

9291 PROMONTORY CI-Indy-1.21 million

13432 Marjac McCordsville- 1.2 million

9244 Bluestone CI Indy- 1.05million

12932 Rocky Pointe Rd. McCordsville- 1 million

13506 Marjac Way-$951,000

13641 LAKE RIDGE LN- McCordsville-$926,341

11033 FALL CREEK RD Indy- $895,000

11030 WOODS BAY LN Indy-$890,000

12106 SILVER SHORE CT Indy- $868,000

13006 ROCKY POINTE RD McCordsville-$860,000

12658 SHOREVISTA DR Indy-$850,000

12967 Water Ridge Dr McCordsville-$840,000

12970 Shoreline McCordsville-$825,000

722 Tamenend Fishers-$800,000

9654 Halsley Indy-$765,000

12642 Shorevista DR Indy-$750,000

9648 Nautilus Indy-$735,000

13419 MARJAC McCordsville-$705,000

10959 HARBOR BAY DR-Fortville-$680,000

9731 DECATUR DR Indy-$650,000

11709 ARMADA CT Fishers-$625,000

11690 Fall Creek Indianapolis-$604,000

12242 Sydney Bay CT Indianapolis-$570,000

8805 Spinnaker Indianapolis-$560,000

11079 Lexi Lane Fortville-$490,000

9670 Decatur Indy- $470,000

11412 Bayhill WA Indy-$375,000

11027 Fall Creek Indy-$350,000


If you would like the square footage or more details on any of these properties feel free to email me at [email protected].  





2008 Dream Home on Geist Reservoir Available For Sale for 2.79 million!

The beautiful Tuscan/Mediterrenean Geist Dream home built in 2008 is still on the market.   Many of my Geist waterfront clients ask me is the Dream house still available.  It sure is!    It started back in 2008 for around 3.5 million and has not sold as of yet and is now available for 2.79 million.  This photo is taken from my boat!   The home sits on a double lot (.55 acres).  The home offers ove 10,000 sqft movie theatre, dramatic details, infinity edge pool with waterfall, and docks right out your back door.   Beautiful views from most windows of Geist Reservoir and a great view of the sunset over the lake!    

Give us a call if you would like to view this or any other waterfront home in the area at 317-814-5530!

See All Geist Waterfront Homes-


Listed by Weichert Realtors


Boating on Geist Reservoir

Geist Reservoir is one of the best places in Fishers, Indiana, within 30 minutes of downtown Indianapolis, to boat.   Geist is a larger reservoir made out of Fall Creek.     I have been boating on Geist Reservoir since I was 16 years old and it is one of my favorite activities.  In fact, when deciding where to build my home, I wanted to live in a neighborhood within a few minute commute to my boat dock.     The marina offers boat slip rentals annually and they run on average around $1800 a season.    If you want a lift it is slightly more.  

The lake allows all types of boats(sailboats, ski boats, and pontoons).    I have a ski boat    The Indianapolis Yacht Club is located on Geist Reservoir as well if you want to boat and belong to a club.     On summer weekends boating is pretty crowded and going to the cove is your best option for still water and lot of relaxation/swimming!   The deepest and widest part of the lake is down by the damn on the Marion County side.  For skiing/wakeboarding go early in the morning, on the weekdays, and in the evenings!    Regardless of your interests, boating on Geist is a great reason to live in Fishers!

See All Geist Waterfront Homes-

If you are considering living on the lake, but want to experience the boating lifestyle first call The Andrew Neal Group at 317-850-3771 to arrange a private boat tour, or call us and we will tell you all about it!

DealwithNeal in Fishers/Geist!

Zogurts, a new and unique Fishers/Geist frozen yogurt shop!

Zogurts is a great place to go for frozen yogurt.    It just recently opened this year in the shopping center at the Northwest corner of Brookschool and Fall Creek in Geist.       Recently I went there with my son after getting off a hot boat ride on Geist, and we both loved it!   I was expecting a tyical ice cream/frozen yogurt place where they take your order and hand you the ice cream.  Instead I found a very orignal concept!   You walk in and you grab your own large cup and choose from their wide assortment of frozen yogurts and fill it yourself.   You then proceed to a buffet where you can pick out and put on your own toppings such as sprinkles, fruit, and hot fudge(a huge selection to choose from!)  They weigh the cup after you are done piling on whatever you want and charge you by the ounce, which seemed very affordable.  It was delicious!    This place was busy at 3 p.m. in the afternoon!      Go check out zogurts soon if you want a unique and refreshing change to your dessert experience in the Fishers/Geist area!

Fishers Living on and around Geist Reservoir

Many of our clients want to enjoy the benefits of living in Fishers on and/or near Geist Reservoir.  Approximately half of Geist Reservoir is in Fishers and/or the Fishers School System(Hamilton Southeastern).   If you want to live in the Fishers and by or on Geist Reservoir you will want to look in the following neighborhoods:

Masthead-One of the original neighborhoods in Geist, Masthead offers custom homes with some of the most beautiful mature properties in Geist.  Part of Masthead is in Fishers and part is in Indianapolis.  Look in the northern part noth of 96 and Fall Creek for Fishers.   From mainbody lake homes to some really great value homes on the cove,   Masthead has options from everyone.   Currently there are 21 homes on the market starting at $221,500 for a 2126sqft ranch foreclosure up to $1.69 million for an 8691sqft waterfront mansion with expansive views of Geist.

Bridgewater-  Featuring HSE schools, this neighborhood has the best location in Geist in my opinion.   The neighborhood sits next to the marina and marina village, within easy walking distance to shopping and fine dining.  Many of the homes are waterfront or have deeded boat docks.  Currently there are 5 homes on the market ranging from $539,000 from a 5442 sqft home across the street from the water to 1.8 million for a 7000sqft Geist waterfront home.

Anchorage- One of the few gated communities, this offers the best value of homes for privacy,HSE schools, and location.   There currently are 3 homes on the market ranging from $475,000 for a 4894 sqft home off the water to 634,000 for a great custom home with deeded boat dock.

Cambridge-  One of the most infamous neighborhoods, which has reached national news with the pilot who stole millions of dollars from clients and faked his own death, this neighborhood borders Geist reservoir and always has a lot of homes for sale.   Currently there are 22 homes for sale ranging from $329,900 to 3.74 million.  This is a great Fishers school neighborhood if you like newer custom homes bordering the lake.

Canal Place-  If you want high end custom construction in Fishers schools, bordering Geist Reservoir, Canal place is the place to be.   Currently there are  8 homes on the market ranging from 449,900 to $950,000 for a waterfront mansion.

Watersedge- If you are looking for newer construction on the water, Wateredge near 104th and Olio Road in Fishers is right on Geist.  This neighborhood was built by Eaton.   There is one 3300 sqft waterfront condo on market for  $569,900.

Regardless of which neighborhood you choose, living in Fishers in the Geist area offers great living for all.  

To See All Fishers/Geist Waterfront homes-