Tag Archives: Windjammer

Which Neighborhood Should I Buy a Home in if I want to live on or near Geist Reservoir?

As a Geist and Fishers expert Realtor and an avid boater on Geist,  I have many people ask the question-Which Neighborhood Should I Buy a


Home in if I want to live on or near Geist Reservoir?   Typically I begin by asking their needs and what type of lifestyle do they want to live.   Here is a quick chart of the neighborhoods  pros/cons-



Masthead-  The original Geist Reservoir neighborhood.  Older, some homes on market may need updating, but lots are very mature many in the woods, you can get a home starting in the 200’s to the upper millions!   There are many streets since it borders a significant portion of Geist.



Windjammer- across the street from water but very nice size yards and a quaint well laid out neighborhood with custom homes from 300k and up.

Sail Place- newer updated maintanence free ranches many with deeded docks and several on the water.  If you do not want to take care of your yard and are retired and this is a second home then this is a great option.

Anchorage- Beautiful well manicured yards, high HOA, gated, beautiful waterfront lots, and many homes have deeded dock.  Top rated Fishers schools!

Breakwater- Beautiful million dollar plus gated community with beautiful large lots

Bridgewater-  If you ask me this is the best location on Geist.  Many homes on the water, walk to Scotty’s Lakehouse(great burgers), Bella Vita, Great waterfront dining, the marina, and homes off water many have Docks. Top Rated HSE(Fishers) schools!

Cambridge- Beautiful neighborhood slightly newer then Masthead, rolling hills, waterviews, two coves right in neighborhood making for a lot of waterviews, HSE schools, a lot of homes for sale at all times, 20 homes currently!

Admirals Bay, Sound, Cove, Pointe- Huge neighborhoods bordering Geist,  you can get more for your money in these neighborhoods since the school system is Lawrence Twp.  There is a good private school nearby.

Feather Cove- another Lawrence Twp School neighborhood bordering Geist, very nice homes several on water!


Whatever your budget/needs you have many options in the Geist Area. Call me to help you navigate to the right neighborhood and I will help you find the perfect home for a great price.  Considering selling your home in Geist?  Call me to discuss our different options on how we can save you thousands and get you the highest price for your home.   Andrew Neal, Re/Max, 317-371-8133